Birthday Cake (White)
Chocolate Birthday Cake
Strawberry Lemon Marble
Orange Chocolate Marble
Half White/Half Chocolate
Specialty Cakes and Cupcake Flavors:
Peanut Butter Cup- Chocolate cake smothered with peanut butter butter cream icing
Chocolate Caranel Peanut Butter Bliss- Two layers of chocolate cake filled with caramel and topped with peanut butter butter cream
Carrot- The perfect carrot cake full of walnuts and topped with your choice of butter cream or cream cheese icing*
Elvis- Banana cake covered with peanut butter butter cream
Mere’s Peanut Butter & Jelly- White cake filled with strawberry filled icing with peanut butter butter cream
German Chocolate- Sweet German chocolate cake filled and topped with coconut pecan icing and chocolate butter cream on the sides and edges
Pumpkin- (Seasonal)- Pumpkin cake iced with your choice of butter cream or cream cheese icing*
Lemon Raspberry Cream- Refreshing! Lemon cake filled with raspberry filling and iced with lemon butter cream icing
Caramel Apple- (Seasonal)- A fall favorite! Apple cake full of chopped apples, walnuts and covered with caramel icing
Triple Chocolate Cherry Chip- Our chocolate cake with a subtle hint of cherry filled and covered with rich chocolate butter cream icing
Amazing Maple- Spice cake covered with maple butter cream
Spiced Maple Bacon- Amazing maple with real bacon bits mixed in the maple butter cream
Chocolate Bourbon Bacon- Choclate cake with bourbon and bacon added to our awesome chocolate butter cream icing
Neapolitin- one layer of strawberry, one layer of chocolate and one layer of white covered with butter cream icing
*Cream Cheese Icing is made with real cream cheese. Unless your cake can be refrigerated until an hour before serving, we recommend using our butter cream icing.
You name it, we can do it. All of our pies are made with a homemade hand rolled crust from a family recipe dating back over 100 years. Order pies for company picnics, cookouts, family gatherings or as a gift to treat someone with something extra wonderful.
Our cookies are made from scratch and baked fresh daily. Many of our recipes have been past down from generations. One of our most popular, buttermilk sugar, dates back over 100 years. Some other favorites: Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Molasses, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Sweet Dream, Brown Sugar Pecan, Lemon Ginger, Oatmeal Raisin, and our Iced Cutout Cookie. Order cookies for your next event or treat your family, friends, clients or coworkers with the best cookie they will ever taste!
Pastries and such - An alternative to donuts and perfect for morning meetings, brunch, tea time or because it sounds good. Cinnamon Rolls, Danish, Turnovers, Coffee Cake, Muffins.
For many holidays we offer a wonderful variety of homemade goodness that can’t be duplicated by any mass producer or grocery bakery.
Thanksgiving we make Pumpkin Rolls, Pumpkin Pies, Pecan Pies, Cut Out Cookies and much more. At Christmas you're sure to find some classic holiday cookies; Mexican Wedding Cakes, Pinwheels, Thumbprint Cookies, Buckeyes, Spritz, Cut Out Cookies and many international favorites all baked from scratch.
Remember Buggy Whip Bakery for any event, any holiday or any gathering that you would like to treat others with a high quality baked good they will never forget!
WE DO BIRTHDAY PARTIES! We can accommodate to 6-8 young bakers.